We’re hiring experienced plumbers! Join the Jake Miller Plumbing team today. Apply Here

Jake Miller Plumbing logo
Toilet Repair

Toilet Replacement: Signs, Steps, and What to Expect

clean bathroom

Toilets are one of the most used fixtures in any household, and when they start to fail, it can throw off your whole routine. Whether it’s constant clogs or a mysterious leak, the signs that you need a toilet replacement can be glaring or subtle. In this blog post, we will guide you through the various indicators that suggest it’s time to replace your toilet, the steps to do so, and what to expect from the process.

Signs You Need a Toilet Replacement

Recognizing the signs that your toilet needs replacement is crucial for maintaining a well-functioning bathroom and avoiding more significant issues down the line. Toilets, like any other household appliances, have a lifespan and will start to show signs of wear and tear over time. Whether it’s frequent clogs, visible cracks, or inefficiency, knowing what to look out for can help you make an informed decision about whether it’s time to replace your toilet. In this section, we’ll dive into the common indicators that suggest your toilet may have reached the end of its useful life.

Frequent Clogs

A toilet that frequently clogs can be more than just a nuisance; it can be a ticking time bomb, especially if you’re dealing with sewage backups or overflows. This is particularly common in older toilets that were not designed to handle today’s usage demands. Not only can frequent clogs lead to unsanitary conditions, but they can also be a symptom of a more significant issue within your plumbing system. If you find yourself reaching for the plunger more often than you’d like, it may be time to consider a toilet replacement.

Cracks in the Porcelain

Cracks often signal that a replacement is in order. Cracks in the porcelain can develop around the tank, bowl, or base, and they can lead to slow leaks that damage your flooring or, in extreme cases, cause flooding. Regularly inspecting your toilet for any signs of cracking can prevent minor issues from turning into major problems.

Consistently Running

A toilet that constantly runs isn’t just irritating; it’s also a waste of water and money. If you’ve already tried fixing the flapper, adjusting the chain, or replacing the float, and the problem persists, it might be time for a new toilet. The constant running can be indicative of worn-out internal components that are costly and impractical to replace individually.

Age of the Toilet

Toilets have a general lifespan of 15 to 20 years, but advancements in toilet technology have made newer models far more efficient in water usage and flushing capabilities. If your toilet is more than 15 years old, you might want to replace it, even if it’s still working reasonably well. Modern toilets offer better performance and can save you money on water bills in the long run.

Wobbling or Shifting

A toilet should be stable and securely anchored to the floor. If you notice your toilet wobbling when you sit on it, it could mean several things. It may indicate that the bolts securing the toilet to the floor have loosened, or worse, it could signify a deteriorating floor or a broken flange. Any of these issues can escalate into a more severe problem if not promptly addressed, making it wise to consider replacing your toilet.

By understanding these signs, you can take proactive steps to replace your toilet before it becomes an urgent issue. Whether you’re dealing with cracks, clogs, or inefficiency, replacing your toilet can offer improved performance and peace of mind.

Steps for Toilet Replacement

Replacing a toilet may seem like an intimidating task, but with the right tools and a well-planned approach, it can be more straightforward than you think. Knowing the steps involved in toilet replacement can help you understand what to expect, whether you decide to tackle the job yourself or hire a professional. In either case, understanding the process can equip you with the knowledge to make informed decisions, ensuring a smoother, more efficient replacement. Here, we break down the key steps involved in toilet replacement, from removal to installation, so you know exactly what’s involved.

Choose a New Toilet

Selecting a new toilet involves more than aesthetics; consider features like water efficiency, flush power, and comfort. Modern toilets come with many functionalities, like bidets and heated seats, to meet different needs.

Prepare the Area

Before beginning, turn off the water supply and drain the existing toilet by flushing it a few times. Remove the old wax ring and any residue.


Follow the manufacturer’s instructions carefully. Most new toilets come with a manual that provides a step-by-step guide. Consider hiring a professional if you’re not confident in your skills.

Test the New Install

Before tightening all the bolts and screws, check for leaks by flushing the toilet a few times. Make sure the toilet is stable and securely anchored.

What to Expect During the Process

  • Time Commitment: A toilet replacement usually takes around 2-4 hours, depending on any unforeseen issues.
  • Costs: The costs can range from $100 to $500 for the toilet itself and around $200 to $300 for professional installation. Some high-end models can cost upwards of $1000.
  • Potential Challenges: You may encounter issues like corroded bolts or a damaged flange that could extend the time and cost of replacement. Always plan for contingencies.

Benefits of Professional Toilet Replacement

When it comes to plumbing, nothing beats the skills and expertise of a professional. They adhere to safety protocols, offer warranties, and ensure that the installation is up to code. If you’re considering a toilet replacement, professional help can offer peace of mind and ensure that the job is done right.

Contact Us

Dealing with a toilet that’s seen better days? Whether it’s frequent clogs or visible cracks that have you concerned, don’t hesitate to reach out for expert advice. At Jake Miller Plumbing, we specialize in toilet replacements, among other plumbing services, to make your bathroom a hassle-free zone.

We look forward to assisting you and ensuring your next toilet replacement is a seamless experience!